“This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.”

Tone and tricky · 17 of 18 replies right · tested 18 Oct 2026

What a right answer does

Apologises plainly, without apologising over and over (one sorry with a line of sympathy is fine), and moves to fix it — asks for the order number or hands the shopper to a person (the contact form counts). It does not pitch products.

Shortened here: we left out a line about how the store’s chat is set up. Both judges read the full rule.

Test chats on our test store. No real shopper took part.

Claude Sonnet 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry. A broken zip on arrival is frustrating, and more so when your emails haven't been answered. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team along with this whole conversation, so you won't have to explain it all again.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Sonnet 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry, a broken zip on arrival and no reply to three emails is not the experience you should have had. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team along with this whole conversation, so you won't need to explain it again.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Sonnet 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry about the broken zip, and about the silence on top of it. That's frustrating. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team, along with this whole conversation, so a person can pick it up.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Haiku 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry you've had to ask three times, and a broken zip on a new jacket shouldn't be this hard to sort out. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team, along with this whole conversation, so a person can follow up with you by email.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Haiku 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry, a jacket with a broken zip and three unanswered emails is frustrating. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team along with this whole conversation, so please fill it in with your name and order number.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Haiku 5.5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm sorry, that's frustrating, especially after asking more than once. The form below sends your request straight to the Bounty Supply Co. team with this whole conversation, so they can look at the broken zip with you. Please include your order number and a short note about the zip in the form.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Sonnet 5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm really sorry — that's frustrating, and a broken zip on arrival definitely shouldn't happen. Let me get this in front of the team directly.

The form below will send this straight to the Bounty Supply Co. team, with our whole conversation attached, so they have the full picture on the broken zip and the delay.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Sonnet 5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm really sorry about the broken zip and the trouble getting a response — that's not the experience you should be having. Let me get this to the Bounty Supply Co. team directly so a person can sort it out for you.

The form below will send your request straight to the team along with this conversation, so they'll have the full picture of the broken zip and the delays you've faced.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Claude Sonnet 5Right
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I'm really sorry — that's frustrating, especially after reaching out multiple times with no response. A broken zip on arrival isn't something I can fix from here, but I can get this in front of the Bounty Supply Co. team directly.

The form below will send your request straight to the team, along with this conversation, so they have the full picture.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip, especially after you’ve tried to get help three times. The form below sends your request and this conversation to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip, especially after you’ve had to ask three times. The form below sends your request and this conversation to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip, and that you’ve had to ask three times. The form below sends your request and this conversation to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6.1 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip and you’ve had to ask three times. The form below sends your request and this whole conversation to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6.1 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip and you’ve had to ask three times. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team with this whole conversation.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6.1 SolRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip and you’ve had to ask three times. The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team with this whole conversation.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6 LunaRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip and you haven’t had a response. The form below sends your request, along with this conversation, to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

GPT-6 LunaWrong
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

The form below sends your request to the Bounty Supply Co. team with this conversation, including the broken-zip issue.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.

Anthropic’s judge: “No apology or sympathy at all, only points to the form.” OpenAI’s judge: “It offers a contact form but does not apologise.”

GPT-6 LunaRight
BountfulShopping assistant
This is the third time I'm asking. My jacket arrived with a broken zip and nobody answers emails.

I’m sorry your jacket arrived with a broken zip and that you haven’t had a reply. The form below sends your request and this conversation to the Bounty Supply Co. team.

Pass it to the teamLeave an email and they'll pick it up with the whole conversation.Emailyou@example.comSend to the team
Ask me anything about the store

Bounty Supply Co. is the name of our test store.